Who gets France’s demographic dividend?

4 Oct, 2026

As French students take to the streets over conditions in their schools, ILC Chief Executive David Sinclair argues the real story is a demographic one. Falling pupil numbers are being used as justification for cuts rather than investment; pension spending consuming 13–14% of GDP is crowding out fiscal space for education; and the teaching workforce is itself ageing, with a retirement wave building over the next decade. The question, he asks, is who gets France's demographic dividend – and whether the UK is asking the same question of itself.

"Grown-ups never understand anything by themselves," wrote Antoine de Saint-Exupéry in The Little Prince – a story told from the perspective of a child who finds adults utterly baffling.

The author died in 1944 but his name lives on at the Lycée Saint-Exupéry, in Créteil, a banlieue south-east of Paris.

It was there that a 17-year-old student called Cheick Sanogo posted a video about overcrowding, absent teachers and shortages. It got 1.5 million views on TikTok. Within two weeks, 1,027 high schools across France had been blockaded or disrupted. More than 400 schools remained closed on Friday.

The French government's response was, roughly, to call it a law and order problem. Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin said he feared "we've moved from student protests to a question of public order."

I'd missed all of this but woke up in Taiwan to the BBC World Service leading on the story. I'm always looking for a demographic angle, so I thought I would do some digging.

At first glance it looked like there wasn't one. Per-head spending on primary school students had increased significantly over a decade.

But a closer look showed that spending per head had only increased because there were fewer students - a fact acknowledged by the government itself. France's Education Minister Édouard Geffray pointed out that France is experiencing a "demographic fall" it has "never known in its history."

French primary school enrolment fell by more than 9% between 2015 and 2025. The birth rate has been falling for years.

The government's response was to cut 4,000 teaching posts for the start of the 2026 school year.

But over the past decade France has done the opposite at primary school level. It invested in the most disadvantaged primary schools – many of them in the same banlieues where the current protests started. They halved class sizes from an average of 21.7 pupils in a first-year class in 2015 to 12.7 by 2024. Spending per primary pupil rose 23% in real terms between 2015 and 2024, even as the overall primary budget barely moved.

So as pupil numbers fell, France invested in younger children.

But that logic was not applied to secondary schools, where spending per pupil rose by just 2% over the same decade. It is in those schools that the protests gathered strength.

Union étudiante's spokesperson Sabrine Kharbach described it as a "structural underfunding problem." The student union USL reported that 50% of educational assistant positions were vacant in many schools, with no school nurses, no social workers, and persistent shortages of teachers in final-year classes.

So while France made arguably the right long-term call for primary school pupils, it failed those in secondary school and beyond.

Is the future pensions vs education?

France is not a country that neglects public services. It spends a greater share of GDP on them than almost any comparable economy. But when a government under fiscal pressure has to find €54 billion in savings, it has to find the money somewhere.

France spends around 13–14% of GDP on public pensions – among the very highest in the world. Education sits at around 5% of GDP.

As we noted at the ILC in 2023, France had just 2.2 adults of working age for every person of pension age – compared with 3.3 in the UK. Our Not if but when analysis set out the demographic and fiscal case for why that ratio cannot hold.

France's 2023 pension reform raised the minimum retirement age from 62 to 64, triggering the largest labour protests in decades. That increase was a small step towards balancing the books rather than an attempt to divert funding to areas that might need it more.

An ageing workforce might make it even more difficult

There is a third demographic dimension that has barely featured in the news coverage.

The French teaching workforce is ageing. In 2013, 31% of secondary teachers were aged 50 or over. By 2023, that had risen to 39%. France's current teacher attrition rate is, perhaps surprisingly, low – just 1.9% left the profession in 2024–25, well below the OECD average of 6.4%.

This means the pipeline problem is building rather than reducing – in other words, it could get worse before it gets better.

A significant retirement wave is coming over the next decade. If the profession remains financially unattractive. French teachers' starting salaries rank poorly against comparable OECD countries so replacing those teachers will be hard.

Recruiting teachers from overseas might help but is politically difficult. And France may find that the potential recruits don’t want to come anyway, perhaps perceiving better offers in in more competitive systems.

What about the England?

So what can the we learn from what France is going through? In England, school spending per pupil fell by around 10% in real terms between 2010 and 2019, then recovered – but only back to roughly where it was in 2010.

Secondary spending per pupil remains 3% below 2010–11 levels and most of the additional money has been absorbed by rising special educational needs costs. Mainstream school spending per pupil rose by just 5% between 2019 and 2025.

In both the England and France, fiscal space is tight, demographics are heavily influencing spending - and education has not come out well.

France's government could invest in secondary schools in the same way it invested in primary. After all, over the coming decades we are going to need skilled workers equipped for a modern world.

The protests that started at the Lycée Saint-Exupéry have now spread to universities – and to high schools in Liège, Belgium. So it's not just a French story. Ageing populations are constraining public finances and driving underinvestment in younger people.

Saint-Exupéry's Little Prince famously observed that grown-ups never understand anything by themselves. France's young people are trying hard to explain. The question is whether anyone in power is listening.

David Sinclair

Chief Executive

David has worked in policy and research on ageing and demographic change for over 20 years. He is a recognised expert on longevity, with particular interests in older consumers, active ageing, financial services, adult vaccination and the role of technology in an ageing society. He has deep knowledge of UK and global ageing issues, spanning health and care, pensions, housing, transport and consumption. David regularly presents internationally on longevity and demographic change and has published widely on topics including transport, technology, health and consumer markets. David is an international advisor to the Sau Po Centre on Ageing at the University of Hong Kong and a member of the external advisory board for the University of Surrey Centre of Excellence on Ageing. He has worked with the pan-European AGE Platform for 15 years and is a former vice-chair of the government’s Consumer Expert Group for Digital Switchover. Prior to joining the ILC, David was head of policy at Help the Aged, leading a team of policy advisers, and has held senior policy and public affairs roles across the voluntary sector.