Rethinking the state pension – time to give people more control

23 Feb, 2026

Lawrence Churchill, ILC's Chair of Trustees and former Chair of NEST poses the challenge: why have a single pension age at all?

Governments worldwide are struggling to balance affordability, sustainability and fairness in their state pension systems, as they were designed in an age when people died shortly after leaving work. This is no longer the case - yet the age at which it can be claimed has not kept pace with longer lives. In the 1960s people spent on average about 20% of their adult lives in retirement – now it is over 30%.

Almost every debate focuses on one question: what should the state pension age (SPA) be? The International Longevity Centre has suggested that, to keep the ratio of workers to non-workers stable in the UK, it would need to rise to 70 by 2040. Denmark has already legislated for this with their SPA rising from 67 today to 68 in 2030, 69 in 2035 and 70 in 2040. Critics, however, argue that many people simply cannot work that long because of poor health, disability or caring duties. These issues are real – and will only grow more pressing.

So perhaps we’re asking the wrong question. Why have a single pension age at all?

Instead, we could offer more choice within a national framework. Imagine replacing a fixed age with a personal “state pension pot” – the total value of someone’s entitlement from the current pension age to average life expectancy. Using today’s figures, that would be around £250,000. The Government Actuary’s Department could set rules on when payments can start, the maximum annual drawdown, and how it keeps pace with inflation. Within those limits, individuals could choose when and how to draw their pension.

If someone lives longer than average, payments would continue for life. If they die early – say, within five years – some of the balance could go to their estate. It would function with the freedom and choice of a personal pension but with the security and fairness of a state-backed system.

Such reform could relieve pressure on public finances while giving people greater control. Seeing a £250,000 fund feels very different from receiving £200 a week – it encourages people to think of their pension as an asset, not a handout.

Affordability could be built in. The size of the pot or withdrawal rates could flex with economic conditions – rising more slowly when growth is weak or borrowing costs are high. Those with serious health issues or caring responsibilities could still draw earlier, keeping the system fair and responsive to individual families’ needs.

Our parents and grandparents often retired with only a few years left to live. Today, someone turning 66 can expect another 20 years, most in good health.

But this is not only about finance. If people are to work longer, employers must adapt too. A voluntary “code for older workers” – similar to those that improved gender and ethnic diversity on company boards – could promote fair recruitment, retraining and workplace design. It would signal that longer working lives are both possible and valued. The Mayfield review on “Keep Britain Working” is already leading the way in this area.

We now have the data, technology and insight to design a more flexible, sustainable system for the future, rather than continue to overstretch a system designed for yesterday. The state should provide a strong foundation – but it need not dictate a single path for everyone.

It’s time to rethink the state pension: not as a rigid promise tied to one age, but as a flexible lifetime asset reflecting longer lives, economic reality and personal choice.

Lawrence Churchill

ILC Chair of Trustees and former Chair of NEST

Lawrence has had an extensive career in Financial Services focused on innovation, governance and improving consumer outcomes. In private sector commercial life, he has been Chief Executive of three insurance groups, Senior Independent Director of BUPA and  currently chairs Clara Pensions and the Independent Governance Committee at Vanguard. In the public sector, he was the founding Chairman of both the Pension Protection Fund and the National Employment Savings Trust as well as chairing the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. He has been a Director of the Personal Investment Authority, The Financial Ombudsman Service and the Board for Actuarial Standards.

In the third sector he has been a Trustee of the Royal Society of Arts, the Employers Forum on Disability, the ILC-UK, the Pensions Policy Institute and has played multiple leadership roles for Business in the Community.

He read Greats at St. John’s College, Oxford, was appointed CBE in 2010 for Public Service and awarded an Honorary Doctorate at the University of Bath in 2024.

Lawrence has been chair of the ILC Board of Trustees since 2024.