Neighbourhood health can’t be another false dawn

20 Mar, 2026

There is much to welcome in the Government’s new neighbourhood health framework. Its ambitions - to bring care closer to home, integrate services around people, and shift towards prevention – are inarguable. But Ben Franklin, ILC’s Deputy Chief Executive, believes that for us to avoid another healthcare related Groundhog Day the framework needs to be serious about upstream prevention and requires genuine financial resource and outcomes-based metrics.  

An ageing society, rising chronic illness, and widening inequalities between people and places show the status quo for supporting our nation’s health is failing. The ILC UK Better Lives Index reveals stark place-based inequalities. In the lowest-ranked areas, avoidable mortality is nearly twice as high, older adults are far more likely to be economically inactive, and child poverty is 2.5 times higher than in the best-performing places. These gaps show how where you live shapes life chances - and why a new neighbourhood health strategy must tackle these deep divides.

For decades, policymakers have promised a “left shift” from hospitals to communities.[1] Each time, the vision has been compelling. Each time, delivery has fallen short. The risk now is not that the grand idea is wrong, but that it becomes the latest reform that seeks to reorganise services without changing outcomes.

On workforce there is the ambition for multidisciplinary neighbourhood teams. Yet despite commitments over the last 20 years progress has been uneven. While some new roles in primary care have expanded, core community nursing – particularly district nursing – has dramatically declined. Between 2009 and 2024, the number of staff recorded in district nurse roles fell by 43%, from 7,643 to 4,322. Without restoring this workforce, neighbourhood health can’t function – these teams are vital for keeping people well at home and preventing hospital admissions.

When it comes to prevention within neighbourhoods, again it features in the rhetoric of the new framework but not the metrics. In health, what gets measured - and funded - gets done. Today, the system is still largely geared towards hospital-based activity and outcomes - appointments, procedures, throughput. There is no consistent, hard-edged accountability framework for keeping people well or narrowing inequalities. If prevention continues to sit outside the core architecture of funding and performance for neighbourhood health, it will remain a distant aspiration.

On investment there is some new funding allocated for primary care, workforce roles and neighbourhood facilities. These are important steps. But transforming care around neighbourhoods requires sustained, clearly identifiable, place-based investment – at a scale that allows local systems to redesign health. Without that, the pull of the acute sector in hospitals will always dominate.

There is also a broader question about what we mean by “neighbourhood health”. If it amounts to better coordination between NHS and social care services, it will help - but it will not transform outcomes. We need to get upstream for that. Health is shaped as much by income, housing, employment and environment as by clinical care. The qualified successes of the 2000-2010 health inequalities strategy came not from health policy alone, but from sustained action across these wider determinants- aligning health, social and economic policy.

None of this is to dismiss the new neighbourhood-based framework. It provides a clearer articulation of the neighbourhood as the organising unit of care and reinforces the case for proactive, integrated support. But if it is to succeed where previous efforts have failed, several critical things must now follow.

Part of this is about moving upstream. Neighbourhood health cannot be delivered by the NHS alone; it requires local alignment between health, economic and social policy - with public health playing a central role in linking services to action on work, housing, income and other wider determinants of health. Similarly, as it stands, public health activities and leadership is present in the rhetoric of the framework but arguably not clearly embedded in the delivery model

It will also be critical to build genuine local capacity quickly. Rapid, large-scale investment is needed in the workforce and infrastructure that make neighbourhood health possible - from district nursing and multidisciplinary teams to community-based hubs. Without this, the model will remain theoretical.

Finally, it’s important to measure what matters. A small set of clear, objective outcomes should sit at the centre of the framework – for example, life expectancy and preventable mortality, economic inactivity due to ill health, alongside behavioural risk factors such as obesity, alcohol and smoking levels – tracked across places and population groups to ensure inequalities are addressed. Without this, we won’t make a dent in boosting local prevention capacity or reducing health inequalities.

The prize is significant. Done well, neighbourhood health could improve outcomes, reduce immediate pressure on hospitals, and support people to live healthier, more independent lives for longer. Done poorly, it will become another missed opportunity - another chapter in the NHS’s long history of promising to shift care into the community without ever getting there.

[1] See for instance: https://www.nhsconfed.org/long-reads/left-shift-mission-impossible

 

Ben Franklin

Deputy Chief Executive

Ben oversees major policy projects and programmes of work for ILC. He is an expert on the intersection of economic and social policy and previously ran the think tank Centre for Progressive Policy, doing ground breaking work on spatial inequality and inclusive growth.

As well as working in think tanks, Ben has worked in the Treasury, Financial Conduct Authority and in the insurance industry.