Guest Blog: Is this the moment for social care?
17 Jul, 2026
With the incoming Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, promising to ‘expend quite a lot of political capital’ on social care and the Casey Commission building support for reform, the political hot potato that successive governments have preferred to ignore may now have its best opportunity for change in 15 years. James Lloyd, Director of Policy and Communications at ARCO, explores how political leadership and public consensus could help lay the foundations for a social care system that works for everyone.
I have very clear memories of watching Andy Burnham, then Health Secretary, launch the ‘Building the National Care Service’ White Paper in a windowless hotel conference room in March 2010.
The White Paper was remarkable for its audacity. It was an ambitious, transformative plan arriving just a few weeks before a general election the government were expected to lose.
But the rest is history. The opposition Conservatives jumped on the proposals with their famous ‘death tax’ posters.
However, a marker was put down. Both before the 2010 election and in the subsequent Labour leadership election, Andy Burnham went further than any other politician in being honest about the hard tax and spending decisions required if meaningful social care reform is to happen.
Roll forward to a June 2026 newspaper interview and Andy Burnham confirmed his passion for social care reform hasn’t dimmed and that he “wouldn’t flinch” from looking at inheritance tax and care charges.
This passion for reform in a high-profile politician has piqued excitement in the social care system, where some have felt frustrated at the measured pace of the Casey Commission’s review into how to build a National Care Service.
As an impressive appearance before the Health Committee recently showed, Baroness Casey has a clear-eyed plan for building public and five-party consensus for reform. She appears to recognise that her biggest and most important challenge is persuading the public to accept the difficult trade-offs required for a properly funded care system. The Commission is in the process of launching a huge public consultation.
Baroness Casey’s approach aligns with the oft-expressed view that to be successful, social care funding reform must have cross-party consensus: implementing reform will likely stretch over a Parliament and the public need to believe that if they contribute to a new system, it will still be in place decades later – not be subject to shifting political sands.
There is now a potential tension here and an irony for the care system: the politician who has arguably been braver than any other in speaking out on social care is reaching the summit of power at precisely the time that a highly effective and insightful Whitehall operator is implementing a process to achieve cross-party and public consensus on reform.
However, there is also huge opportunity and what happens next depends on to what extent Andy Burnham and Baroness Casey can reinforce each other’s strengths and efforts.
Let’s start with the obvious. Labour MPs are unlikely to want any re-appearance of the death tax posters – several newspapers have already begun stoking anxiety on this. So there is an opportunity for a Burnham government to lean on Baroness Casey to take the brickbats for telling the public the price of a better care system and to deter any political opportunism by other parties.
The Casey Commission’s efforts to drive public debate on reform can also be elevated by Downing Street, which can bring to bear the full power of its pulpit to put the Commission and social care on the national agenda. Baroness Casey has given speeches to the LGA, ADASS and the Nuffield Trust among others. Her next speech should be to the nation in Downing Street with an introduction from the PM.
The Casey Commission can also rubber-stamp the early implementation of some basic building-blocks of a National Care Service that could be adopted during this Parliament and taken forward ahead of five-party talks concluding.
But this will not be easy. There is some low-hanging fruit, such as adopting New Zealand-style tenure reforms to turbo-charge new housing-with-care provision in all regions of the country.
But identifying building blocks that are widely salient with the public, fundable and deliverable will be hard given the limited time left in this Parliament for new legislation and Treasury resistance to opening up the current departmental spending round.
Changes also need to be things that will build public momentum for a National Care Service and align with how people think about social care.
What can be done?
Andy Burnham’s No.10 North plan shows an eye for the importance of the optics of institutional architecture. In a similar vein, the role of social care in Whitehall could be rewired by making the role of Care Minister a joint post that sits in DHSC and MHCLG. At a stroke, this would end the anomaly of the Care Minister being outside the room when negotiations with HM Treasury on social care budgets take place. It would also set the stage for more joined-up social care policymaking. (And there is precedent: an early, widely welcomed move by this government gave the Pensions Minister seats in both DWP and HM Treasury).
The means-test thresholds in the English local authority care system have been frozen since 2010. Relinking them to inflation would be a small, but symbolic act that would signal change and intent (they could even be back-dated to the start of the Parliament). Announcing the annual uprating of the thresholds in each year’s Budget alongside the new State Pension levels would also be a pointed reminder to politicians, journalists and the public of the imperative for reform.
But the best approach might be to pivot the focus to unpaid carers. You are still much more likely to give or receive unpaid care than you are to receive domiciliary or residential care, and many people still think of informal care when they think of social care. Support for carers in the Care Act is probably one of its least used elements. Building the ‘carers pillar’ of a National Care Service is probably the one that requires the least amount of legislation or organisational disruption. Additional new workplace rights for social care would have limited costs for the Exchequer. New, guaranteed breaks for carers would be relatable across the population.
In short, this is the best window for reform of the social care system in 15 years.
James Lloyd
Director of Policy & Communications at ARCO
James joined ARCO in September 2022 and brings over 20 years’ experience in public policy, strategic influencing, communications and research. His expertise spans key policy areas including ageing, adult social care, housing, pensions, and education.
James has held senior advisory roles at the heart of UK policymaking, including as Senior Adviser to the Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit and as Independent Adviser to the Opposition during cross‑party social care reform negotiations. He has also worked with several leading think tanks and a major national education charity.
James has been called as an expert witness by multiple parliamentary bodies, including the Public Administration Select Committee, Communities and Local Government Committee, Health Committee, and a Pension Schemes Bill Committee. His media experience includes live appearances on BBC Radio 4’s Today and You and Yours, as well as BBC Newsnight.

