Guest blog: Long Shadows – how today’s child poverty shapes tomorrow’s Britain
17 Jul, 2025
Why does an empty fridge in childhood shape a hospital chart at 70? Jack Eddy reflects on the the impact of child poverty on longevity and on the economy.
Let’s start this blog with a hypothetical:
It is a surprisingly warm June evening in Blackpool. Joan, 81, is sitting close to the dormant electric fire in the front room of her bungalow. She has just learnt, via the six-o’clock news, that her restored Winter Fuel Payment will arrive later this year. She smiles; electricity has become eye-wateringly expensive since her fixed tariff ended and she was dreading the post-summer chill, when she would struggle to meet the heating bill.
Less than a mile away, in a two-bed terrace on Central Drive, nine-year-old Oliver is finishing homework beneath a single energy-saving bulb. His mother, Sarah, owes the same supplier £280; the pre-payment meter clicks off regularly and the house never really warms in the winter, which is particularly difficult for Oliver and his two younger siblings. Sarah dreads the coming winter and doesn’t quite know how she is going to make ends meet. Supper is toast with tinned spaghetti hoops. Oliver’s class teacher is quietly worried about his weight and the purple shadows under his eyes.
The Chancellor’s early summer Fiscal Event that pleased Joan did nothing for Oliver and his mum. By reinstating the Winter Fuel Payment (WFP) for almost every pensioner - an outlay of roughly £1.25 billion a year - while retaining the two-child limit on Universal Credit and Child Tax Credit, a measure that ’saves’ an almost identical £1.3 billion annually, the government made a choice about who matters when money is tight.
Pensioner poverty is real; child poverty is also real. That choice has consequences on those living through it now and stretches far beyond this winter’s electricity bills.
The arithmetic of need
On the government’s own figures, 4.3 million children, or 30 per cent of all UK under-18s, were living in relative poverty after housing costs in 2022/23. The equivalent rate for pensioners is around 16 per cent, or 1.9 million people. Both statistics are troubling, but the stark reality is that children are almost twice as likely as pensioners to be poor.
Yet the numbers signify something much heavier and more consequential than present-day hardship: Poverty alters bodies. In the latest local-area tables from the Office for National Statistics (ONS), a boy like Oliver in Blackpool can expect to live 73.1 years, while another “Oliver” born in Hart, Hampshire, will reach 83.4 years.
But life expectancy is only half the story. Healthy life expectancy – or years lived free of disabling illness - presents an even crueller geography. Blackpool males born today average 51.7 healthy years; in more affluent Wokingham, a newborn boy enjoys close to 70 years in good health. In other words, Oliver is forecast to spend almost two decades longer in ill health than a peer two hundred miles south of him.
A biography written in biology
Why does an empty fridge in childhood shape a hospital chart at 70? As ever, longevity means moving your thought processes away from the immediate, however difficult the immediate may be, and trying to take the long view.
Longitudinal research is beginning to set out the clear roadmap linking childhood poverty with difficulties in adulthood. Analyses of the 1946, 1958 and 1970 birth cohorts – three generations born before, during and after the creation of the NHS – show that low childhood socio-economic position continues to predict premature mortality up to the age of 70: universal free health care has not erased the life-course ‘scar’.
More recent evidence is equally unforgiving. In May 2025, a cross-national study of eighty thousand adults aged 50 and over, led by Dr Gindo Tampubolon, showed that childhood deprivation lifts the probability of being frail in later life by 11 percentage points, even after adult income, education and health care systems are allowed for.
The effect is partly biological: in utero malnutrition switches on genes that heighten inflammatory responses; chronic stress floods the developing brain with cortisol, disrupting immune regulation; continued malnutrition in childhood leads to further growth issues.
It is also social: children who start school hungry find learning harder, achieve less, and are ultimately filtered into lower-paid, riskier work.
Put simply, this combination of problems, which stems from disadvantages in youth, results in an adult who is more likely to be less financially secure and productive, while also being more reliant on services.
For Oliver, that means his present weight and sleep problems are likely not passing annoyances but the opening paragraphs in a long medical file, one that could close a decade earlier than it should.
The bill nobody sees
If human suffering were not argument enough, there is the Treasury ledger. The Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG) now prices the annual cost of child poverty at £39 billion (2023 prices), through the lost tax revenue, higher welfare spending, extra health service pressure and the criminal justice bill that it leads to. To picture that sum, line it up against the entire 2024/25 defence equipment budget and then double it.
Contrast those unseen costs with the government’s ‘saving’ from the two-child limit. According to CPAG, the policy holds 400,000 children below the poverty line and pushes a new cohort of roughly 100 children into poverty every single day. Meanwhile, the Exchequer saves around £1.3 billion a year.
It is difficult to design a fiscal measure whose long-term price so dwarfs its short-term gain.
Evidence of better bets
There is, happily, proof that the story can be changed. In May, the Institute for Fiscal Studies revisited its long-running evaluation of Sure Start children’s centres, a programme whose funding was slashed after 2010. The new working paper concludes that every £1 invested returns £2.05 across a lifetime of higher earnings, lower NHS use and improved educational outcomes, with many of the benefits arriving in adolescence and early adulthood, not just the nursery years.
Economists call such returns “high policy multipliers”: money that works harder than its face value. Welfare support aimed at low-income families sits in the same league. The Office for Budget Responsibility’s own data highlight that income-related benefits are nearly twice as beneficial in the short term compared to universal transfers, such as the Winter Fuel Payment.
Put bluntly, and where limited resources dictate necessary trade-offs, £1 to nine-year-old Oliver’s mother delivers more economic bang than £1 to 81-year-old Joan.
An ageing lens
All these equations acquire urgency when viewed through Britain’s demographic telescope. By 2050, one person in four will be over 65. The dependency ratio, or pensioners per hundred working-age adults, will rise from 62 to 73 unless older people work significantly longer and younger cohorts are healthy and productive enough to support them.
Cold statistics speak the warm language of inter-dependence: today’s children are tomorrow’s carers, taxpayers and innovators. In other words, children will be adults one day too. Undercutting their start is a luxury an ageing society cannot afford.
Think again of Oliver reaching 50 in 2066. Suppose the Treasury keeps its current stance: the two-child limit stays, real-terms child benefit stagnates, early-years funding remains patchwork. Oliver’s generation could enter mid-life with poorer health, lower skills and even weaker attachment to the labour-market.
That cohort, which in absolute numbers is larger than the wartime baby boomers, will hit the NHS just as the retirement wave crests. The outcome is not hard to model: a continued downward doom loop of higher treatment costs, lower tax receipts, tougher borrowing conditions and renewed pressure to trim the state pension or further raise the pension age.
The problem is, by this point, the doom loop will be so ingrained, so chiselled into the foundations of the UK, that it would be impossible to correct it.
How to weave a “golden thread”
If government policy is to pay forward rather than merely balance this year’s departmental accounts, it needs a unifying test.
Something that could be called the “golden thread”: whatever a department’s brief – be it transport, energy, housing, defence – it should ask what does this decision do to a child’s chances?
So how do we do this?
First, the government should set out legislation requiring a child-impact duty. Whitehall already publishes equality impact statements. By extending that principle to child poverty, it would make invisible trade-offs visible while also working to alter the culture of short-termism that is prevalent throughout Whitehall, but particularly in the Treasury.
Then we need to start turning the safety-net into a springboard. Lifting the two-child limit would, at a stroke, raise nearly a million children out of deep poverty and cost a rounding error in the national accounts. However, uprating child benefit with average earnings rather than the CPI would preserve its value over time, ensuring that this safety-net is effective longer term.
Third, early-years infrastructure must be rebuilt. Sure Start’s documented returns justify its rebirth and locating centres in the poorest quintile of neighbourhoods would anchor support where it is most needed and would have the biggest impact.
Fourth, create a focus on housing-led health. Augmenting the Warmer Homes initiative and potentially redirecting a slice of the Winter Fuel Payment budget to support the insulation of the draughtiest family homes could cut respiratory admissions this decade and energy bills for decades to come.
And finally, ensure accountability for the “golden thread” through targets. This approach is far from unusual in government policy – in the carbon policy the Climate Change Act binds governments to five-year budgets, for example. If a parallel statutory goal, say to halve the healthy life expectancy gap at birth by 2035, were to be introduced across all government departments, it would convert the “golden thread” from slogan to lodestar.
With this, suddenly child poverty, like climate change, becomes everyone’s business across Whitehall.
A decision that belongs to all of us
Opponents of child-centred policy often invoke fairness to older people - Joan has paid tax all her life; why deny her warmth? This is, of course, a very fair point and I’ll return to my initial statement that “pensioner poverty is real”.
The objection, however, misreads solidarity. Making Oliver resilient is the surest way to guarantee Joan’s future care. The immense success of the post-war welfare state was to recognise inter-generational reciprocity, not set the young and old in budgetary opposition.
In the months ahead, Treasury ministers will once again weigh departmental bids. The easiest path will be to protect the familiar - pensions, potholes, maybe something on immigration… whether it’s justified or not – and shave the marginal programmes that lack vocal lobbies.
The long shadows those decisions cast are already visible in the mortality tables – and remember, these are the government’s own data, they should know this.
We can either take the decisions to bring light to these shadows, or we can ignore them further and suffer the costs. Oliver’s healthy years, Joan’s secure winters, and Britain’s fiscal balance sheet all point in the same direction: investing in children is the most adult thing a society can do.
References
- House of Lords Library, Child Poverty: Statistics, causes and the UK’s policy response (1 Feb 2024)
- End Child Poverty Coalition, Local Child Poverty Statistics 2024 (18 Jun 2025)
- Age UK, Poverty and financial disadvantage in later life (May 2024)
- ONS, Life expectancy for local areas of Great Britain: 2021–2023 (Dec 2024)
- ONS, Healthy life expectancy in the England and Wales: between 2011 to 2013 and 2021 to 2023 (Dec 2024) eith data for Scotland and Northern Ireland found here: https://www.nomisweb.co.uk/reports/lmp/la/contents.aspx
- Tampubolon G., Growing up in poverty, growing old in frailty: the life course shaping of health in the United States, England and Europe-a prospective and retrospective study, Scientific Reports 15: e99929 (May 2025)
- Bann D. et al., Socio-economic circumstances across life and premature mortality, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 75(2):193-201 (2025).(jech.bmj.com)
- Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG), The cost of child poverty in 2023 (Oct 2023) and The two-child limit – our position (July 2025)
- Institute for Fiscal Studies, Sure Start’s Wide-Ranging and Long-Lasting Benefits Highlight Impact of Integrated Early-Years Support (22 May 2025)
- GOV.UK press release, Nine Million Pensioners to Receive Winter Fuel Payments This Winter (11 Jun 2025)
- The Health Foundation, Healthy life expectancy target: the scale of the challenge (7 March 2022)

Jack Eddy
Regular contributor
