Retiring peers at 80: an idea the government should let go
6 Nov, 2026
We abolished the Default Retirement Age in 2011 on the principle that age is not a proxy for ability. Thirteen years later, the Government is proposing to do exactly that to the House of Lords. David Sinclair argues that there are bold, brave reforms that could make Parliament better at thinking long-term. This isn’t one of them.
Sometimes, when you see a manifesto commitment that is genuinely daft, you hope it will quietly disappear. The mandatory retirement age for Lords at 80 was one I’d filed in that category. It seems I was wrong.
Earlier this week, Baroness Twycross confirmed at the despatch box that the Government remains committed to the pledge. No specific age was given this time, but the Labour manifesto said 80.
Last year, the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee published a major report on preparing Britain for an ageing society. It concluded that the UK is woefully unprepared. It was serious, rigorous, important work – exactly the kind of scrutiny that the Lords exists to provide.
Around a third of the current members of this committee are over 80. The new chair, Lord Burns – former Permanent Secretary to the Treasury and head of the Government Economic Service – is 82. Lord Butler of Brockwell is 88. Lord Young of Cookham is 85. Lord Razzall is 83. Under the Government’s manifesto commitment, all four would be gone.
Baroness Greengross – founder of the International Longevity Centre and one of the most formidable advocates on ageing this country has produced – was still an active peer in her eighties. She died in 2022 at 86, having spent her final years doing what she had always done: pressing governments to take the long view on demographic change. Under an 80-year rule, she would have been shown the door years before her death.
The end of age discrimination in work
In 2011, the UK scrapped the Default Retirement Age. The consensus was that you cannot assume someone has lost the capacity to contribute simply because they’ve passed a particular birthday. Age is not a proxy for ability, or for judgment, or for relevance.
That was the right then and it is now.
When I travel I am still occasionally startled to find countries with mandatory retirement ages embedded in law. South Korea, one of the fastest-ageing societies on the planet, still allows workers to be forced out at 60 in many sectors – years before their state pension begins at 65. The result is a gap in income, in purpose, and in contribution that serves nobody well.
The UK spent much of the last decade being a quiet advocate for the idea that age should not determine economic or civic participation.
Introducing a mandatory retirement age for the second chamber – however well-intentioned the broader Lords reform – sends exactly the wrong signal.
There are better ways to improve Parliament
A few years ago, ILC set out what genuinely ambitious parliamentary reform on ageing might look like.
We proposed a new cross-cutting Parliamentary Select Committee – a Demographic Change Committee, modelled on the Environmental Audit Committee – with a remit to hold government departments to account on how they respond to longevity.
We also proposed that any legislation using age as a proxy should be required to justify that use explicitly on the face of the Bill. That second proposal would apply directly to the legislation the Government is now planning. It would be a short Bill. The justification section might need some work.
If the Government wanted to go further, it could look at citizens’ panels with the power to make proposals directly to Parliament on ageing society. Or – and I will admit this is a long-standing view of mine – it could consider random selection for the Lords. It is the only mechanism I can think of that would produce a second chamber genuinely representative of the country, including of people at every stage of life.
None of these proposals uses age as a blunt instrument.
There are bold, brave things that could be done to make Parliament better at thinking about the long term and the ageing society we are all becoming part of.
Mandatory retirement is not one of them. It is not reform. It is ageism.
David Sinclair
Chief Executive
David has worked in policy and research on ageing and demographic change for over 20 years. He is a recognised expert on longevity, with particular interests in older consumers, active ageing, financial services, adult vaccination and the role of technology in an ageing society. He has deep knowledge of UK and global ageing issues, spanning health and care, pensions, housing, transport and consumption. David regularly presents internationally on longevity and demographic change and has published widely on topics including transport, technology, health and consumer markets. David is an international advisor to the Sau Po Centre on Ageing at the University of Hong Kong and a member of the external advisory board for the University of Surrey Centre of Excellence on Ageing. He has worked with the pan-European AGE Platform for 15 years and is a former vice-chair of the government’s Consumer Expert Group for Digital Switchover. Prior to joining the ILC, David was head of policy at Help the Aged, leading a team of policy advisers, and has held senior policy and public affairs roles across the voluntary sector.

