Expert on tap, not expert on top

3 Sep, 2026

With the new Prime Minister staking his reputation on giving power back to places, last night Professor Kate Ardern brought a practitioner's account of what happens when you hand power back to communities.

Kate delivered the third Greengross Lecture in Westminster, making a solid case for "Expert on tap rather than expert on top."

Kate served as Director of Public Health for Wigan between 2008 and 2022. It was there that she helped design the Wigan Deal – a citizen-led, asset-based approach to public health that has become something of a national reference point.

The council bought an Ikea sofa, loaded it onto a van, and took it around the borough. Officers sat down with residents and talked. They learnt things they didn’t expect - mental health for example, ranked higher as a local priority than the professionals had assumed.

Through the lecture Kate kept coming back to the point that communities know what they need. The Wigan deal required "both the politicians and the professionals, as well as the public" to go on "a journey from paternalism to people power."

The Kings Fund, which independently evaluated the Wigan Deal in 2019, captured the outcome in one line: the programme had given staff "their vocation back." The deal was built around 10 operating principles, including training staff in ethnography, redesigning commissioning around outcomes rather than activity – what Kate described as "transformational rather than transactional" – and investing in over 23,000 Community Health Champions across the borough.

ILC's own UK Better Lives Index highlights the need for a place-based approach to long lives. Life expectancy at birth is nine years longer in Richmond upon Thames than in Blackpool. Kate's argument is that no national model, however well-designed, can close that gap from the centre. She argued that the solutions must be built where people live.

"Pandemics begin and end with communities," Kate said, quoting from a documentary she contributed to after the covid response. She is right – but the principle extends well beyond pandemics. The chronic conditions that will shape the health of all of us as we age are not solved in hospitals. They are shaped by housing, employment, green space, social connection and the strength of local relationships.

Andy Burnham is now Prime Minister. He was Greater Manchester's Mayor when the pandemic hit, and Kate was his Director of Public Health for Health Protection across the region. Kate described how it took her four months to get patient-level covid data from central government – data she needed to identify and control local outbreaks. Centralisation didn't protect people.

Kate argued that negotiating drug prices, regulating medicines, setting national standards, running highly specialised low-volume clinical services belong at the centre. But she emphasised that most health commissioning can and should sit at combined authority level.

Kate made the case for devolved workforce planning. "We're still training the workforce of yesterday," she said. "That might not be the workforce we need today or tomorrow." The answer, in her view was to devolve workforce planning to combined authorities, anchor it to local universities and colleges, and create the conditions for teaching boroughs – not just teaching hospitals.

The Burnham government has the political capital, and the personal biography, to make devolution real rather than rhetorical. The lesson from Wigan – and from Greater Manchester's pandemic response – is that the building blocks already exist. What's needed now is the courage to devolve workforce planning alongside everything else, and the willingness to fund it through long-term settlements rather than competitive bids for small, siloed pots of money.

Baroness Greengross wrote in 1985 that "anything we recognise as finite can become more acutely pleasurable, and as the prospect of available time decreases, the desire to experience life fully and to enjoy all it has to offer may well increase." That desire is what good public health should serve. A system that helps us live rather than merely keeping us alive.

The question for the Prime Minister – who knows this territory better than most – is whether the next spending review will match the ambition of the rhetoric. Kate Ardern has given him a blueprint. Perhaps there should be a budget line for Ikea sofas.

The Greengross Lecture

The Greengross Lecture was established in honour of Baroness Sally Greengross OBE, who founded ILC-UK in 1997 and shaped the debate on longevity in this country for decades. Sally died in 2022, but her conviction – that a society's response to longer lives reveals everything about its values – remains very much alive. The inaugural lecture was delivered by Ashton Applewhite, who challenged us to imagine a world without ageism. The second, in 2024, saw Professor David Halpern explore how behaviour shapes wealth, health and happiness as we age.

You can watch Kate Arden's lecture via the button below.

David Sinclair

Chief Executive

David has worked in policy and research on ageing and demographic change for over 20 years. He is a recognised expert on longevity, with particular interests in older consumers, active ageing, financial services, adult vaccination and the role of technology in an ageing society. He has deep knowledge of UK and global ageing issues, spanning health and care, pensions, housing, transport and consumption. David regularly presents internationally on longevity and demographic change and has published widely on topics including transport, technology, health and consumer markets. David is an international advisor to the Sau Po Centre on Ageing at the University of Hong Kong and a member of the external advisory board for the University of Surrey Centre of Excellence on Ageing. He has worked with the pan-European AGE Platform for 15 years and is a former vice-chair of the government’s Consumer Expert Group for Digital Switchover. Prior to joining the ILC, David was head of policy at Help the Aged, leading a team of policy advisers, and has held senior policy and public affairs roles across the voluntary sector.