The value of advice and the £47,000 answer

11 Aug, 2026

I remember a meeting with a senior Conservative MP about fifteen years ago. The Retail Distribution Review was being implemented and we had concerns about how to ensure that the new regulations would provide a platform to improve access to financial advice and guidance, rather than limit it to those willing to pay.

We met a sceptical audience. The politician wasn't convinced that advice worked and said he himself wouldn't use an adviser.

The financial services industry has long faced a trust problem – sometimes fair, sometimes not. Take annuities, routinely framed as poor value products, when in reality they are a useful tool for managing the risk of outliving your money.

We were making the case for an intervention where scepticism was high and evidence was thin.

What followed was a decade of research and convening to understand the evidence and get it out.

Putting a number on advice

Our first piece of work – produced with Royal London – used longitudinal data to ask: were people who took financial advice between 2001 and 2006 measurably better off a decade later?

The answer was yes. Those who received professional financial advice were, on average, £40,000 better off.

When the report launched in 2017, we attracted strong national as well as trade media coverage. Professional Adviser and International Investment, among others, ran the story in the trade press.

The value of advice goes beyond wealth

While our quantitative research told us that advice was valuable, our qualitative work Peace of Mind told us *why*.

People we spoke to described not primarily wealth, but confidence, control and the reassurance of knowing that someone knowledgeable was watching their back.

It turned out the industry was right in what they were telling us. Financial advice isn't just about building assets – it builds psychological security that allows people to make better decisions, sleep a little easier, and approach the future with less anxiety.

As we age and the financial decisions we face become more consequential – when to draw down a pension, how to manage income in retirement, how to protect what we have built.

The irony is that qualitative research gets less coverage. Journalists want a number. The £40,000 figure was easy to put in a headline. "People feel more confident" is harder to sell to a news editor. But if we are serious about understanding what advice truly does for people, the qualitative picture is indispensable – and arguably the more important of the two.

A decade on – still being cited

What has surprised us most is how long the research has kept getting picked up. There isn't much research, almost a decade on, that is still being quoted and referenced regularly.

When we published the updated report *What it's worth* in 2019, a wave of IFA firms actively republished the findings in their own client-facing content (including F0ster Denovo; Wren Sterling; Questa Chartered; Providus Financial.

And by 2019, the value of advice had increased to £47,000. With this research we found the effect was larger, proportionally, for people on lower incomes. And those who maintained an ongoing advisory relationship were left with pension pots around 50% higher than those who had consulted an adviser just once.

In 2023, the research crossed into academia: a peer-reviewed systematic literature review published in Accounting & Finance cited our work. As recently as March 2026, M&G – one of the UK's major asset managers – was drawing on both the 2017 report and *Peace of Mind* to explain the value of advice to its own customers.

And a House of Commons Library Research Briefing published in May 2026 – nearly seven years after What it's worth – cites our findings directly, drawing on them to make the case that professional advice produces meaningful, lasting financial outcomes.

Trade publications and money pages in national newspapers return to it whenever the advice gap enters the news cycle.

We've influenced the policy debate

When we first talked about the advice–guidance divide, we called for a formal distinction between regulated advice and simpler consumer support. Pension Wise launched (following pension freedoms which made the case for advice and guidance more necessary) free, impartial guidance for those approaching retirement with defined contribution pensions, formalising that distinction in practice.

In 2021, the FCA introduced investment pathways: structured defaults to stop non-advised consumers drifting into poor decumulation outcomes – a direct application of the principle that defaults and nudges matter far more than disclosure alone.

And in 2023, the Consumer Duty fundamentally reoriented the regulatory framework around consumer outcomes rather than compliance box-ticking, mirroring precisely what ILC had argued for over a decade.

More recently, the FCA's Advice Guidance Boundary Review creates a new regulatory category called targeted support, designed to reach the millions of people who fall between full financial advice and generic guidance.

Problems remain, however. Auto-enrolment transformed savings culture on the accumulation side – a success story that vindicated the case for well-designed defaults.

But the advice gap at scale is structurally unresolved. The proliferation of small pension pots, which ILC flagged early, has grown larger rather than smaller. And as we age and the complexity of financial decision-making increases – when to access a pension, how to manage income across a longer retirement, how to plan for care costs – the stakes of that gap become progressively higher.

Not every argument ILC made was won. But the framework we set out – that disclosure alone does not change behaviour, that guidance and advice serve different functions for different people, and that defaults shape outcomes as powerfully as any regulatory rule – has proven durable.

What happens now

Our work on the value of advice shows what good research can do when it is paired with strong communications and genuine convening power. The evidence base we built has shaped policy debate, influenced regulatory thinking, and continued to circulate – in parliament, in the press, and we are told, in advisers' conversations with clients.

I don't know how many more years organisations will quote our £47,000 figure – it's clearly very dated now. We though, can celebrate the long-term impact of a programme of work – in driving policy change as well as highlighting that advice does have value.

Despite the success we played a part in, fewer than one in six people in the UK currently seek financial advice. Women remain particularly underserved. The advice gap – an estimated 18 million adults who could benefit but don't engage – remains stubbornly wide. Our research has helped shift the conversation, informed regulatory reform, and given the industry a credible evidence base to build on. But the mission is far from complete.

If you are interested in work with ILC to addressing these ongoing challenges - do get in touch.

Find out more: work with us

David Sinclair

Chief Executive

David has worked in policy and research on ageing and demographic change for over 20 years. He is a recognised expert on longevity, with particular interests in older consumers, active ageing, financial services, adult vaccination and the role of technology in an ageing society. He has deep knowledge of UK and global ageing issues, spanning health and care, pensions, housing, transport and consumption. David regularly presents internationally on longevity and demographic change and has published widely on topics including transport, technology, health and consumer markets. David is an international advisor to the Sau Po Centre on Ageing at the University of Hong Kong and a member of the external advisory board for the University of Surrey Centre of Excellence on Ageing. He has worked with the pan-European AGE Platform for 15 years and is a former vice-chair of the government’s Consumer Expert Group for Digital Switchover. Prior to joining the ILC, David was head of policy at Help the Aged, leading a team of policy advisers, and has held senior policy and public affairs roles across the voluntary sector.