Guest blog: Pensions – from technical reform to democratic renewal
5 Aug, 2026
In her guest blog, Alexandra Miles, from Legal & General Asset Management, argues that the next phase of pensions reform cannot be shaped by technical expertise alone. As Founder and Chair of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries’ Pension Gap Working Party and Co-chair of the Pensions Equity Group’s Data and Research arm, Alexandra makes the case for giving citizens a meaningful role in deciding how the UK’s pension system should respond to profound social and economic change.
If pensions reform is ultimately about societal choices, citizens must have a meaningful role in making them.
For much of the past two decades, pensions policy has been one of the UK's quieter success stories. Automatic enrolment has transformed participation in workplace pensions, bringing millions of people into long-term saving. The State Pension has become simpler and more effective at reducing poverty. The reforms initiated by the Turner Commission established a durable cross-party consensus that has survived multiple governments and economic shocks.
But the challenge facing policymakers today is fundamentally different from the one they faced twenty years ago. Then, the question was simply how to get people saving. Now, it is whether the system will deliver adequate, fair and sustainable retirement incomes in a world characterised by greater longevity, economic uncertainty and widening inequalities.
Around 15 million people are projected to be undersaving for retirement. Only around 4% of self-employed workers are currently saving into a pension. The ratio of pensioners to working-age adults continues to rise, while changing patterns of housing mean that by 2050 half of pensioners in poverty are projected to be renters. They are symptoms of a broader challenge: how we adapt our retirement system to far-reaching social and economic change.
The recently relaunched Pensions Commission has been tasked with helping answer that question. Its interim report rightly argues that the UK now needs a renewed national settlement on pensions. Many of the questions the Commission must address are not purely technical.
How should responsibility for retirement security be shared between individuals, employers and the state? How should costs and benefits be distributed across generations? What level of retirement income should society consider adequate? Which inequalities should policymakers prioritise addressing first?
One of the clearest conclusions from the Deliberative Democracy and Pensions scoping project is that these are questions about values, not questions that can be resolved through analysis alone. The project explored whether deliberative democratic methods could help address some of the most difficult challenges facing pensions policy. The answer was a resounding yes.
Delivered by the team at New Citizen Project, the scoping phase was made possible through the support of a broad cross-sector coalition. Funding and steering group input was provided by organisations including the Standard Life Centre for the Future of Retirement, Institute and Faculty of Actuaries, Nest, the People’s Partnership (People’s Pension), Nest, and Pensions UK. A wide range of contributors—from Age UK and the ABI to the Department for Work and Pensions, the Money and Pensions Service, The Pensions Regulator, ShareAction and the Trades Union Congress—also shaped the findings through interviews, workshops and challenge.
The case for citizen deliberation is particularly strong given the steady shift in responsibility for retirement outcomes from institutions to individuals through the growth of defined contribution pensions. Yet ordinary savers still have very limited influence over the design of the system itself.
At the same time, public trust in institutions remains fragile. Policymakers are being asked to make long-term decisions in a more fragmented and uncertain political environment than existed when the Turner Commission first reported. In this context, building consensus matters as much as identifying technically optimal solutions.
Following the scoping phase, we have developed a proposal for a national Citizens’ Assembly on the future of UK pensions. The proposal would bring together around 100 citizens, selected through civic lottery to reflect the diversity of the UK population, for more than 30 hours of structured learning and deliberation. Participants would hear evidence from experts, engage with competing perspectives and work through the trade-offs inherent in pensions policy before developing recommendations for policymakers.
The objective is to strengthen expertise, representative democracy and political leadership, not replace them. Good policymaking requires evidence. Durable policymaking requires legitimacy. Deliberative processes can help provide both by combining expert analysis with informed public judgement.
The value of such an approach extends beyond pensions. As societies age, governments will increasingly face difficult decisions about intergenerational fairness, public spending, work, care and retirement. These are precisely the kinds of issues where democratic legitimacy becomes a critical policy asset.
The relaunch of the Pensions Commission is an opportunity. We have the chance not only to rethink pensions policy, but also to rethink how we make decisions about our collective future. That is the case for giving citizens a seat at the table while the Commission's work is still being shaped.
A Citizens’ Assembly is a practical way to make that happen.
We are now seeking partners, funders and collaborators to take this work into the next phase. If you are interested in supporting, shapng or participating in the development of a national deliberative process on the future of pensions, we would welcome the opportunity to engage.
To learn more about the evidence and thinking underpinning this proposal, read the full scoping report: DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY AND PENSIONS | New Citizen Project

Alexandra Miles
Legal & General Asset Management
Alexandra Miles has worked at Legal & General Asset Management for over a decade, the majority of these focused on Defined Contribution schemes. Her team runs the main default investment strategy for L&G’s DC customers. She is the DC sustainability lead within the team and also leads on broader DC research and thought leadership, using internal insights and external partnerships to further enhance L&G’s future offering. She is a qualified actuary with a MSc in Actuarial Finance and a Meng in Aerospace Engineering.
Outside of work, Alexandra is Founder chair of the Institute & Faculty of Actuaries Pension Gap Working Party and Co-chair of the Data and Research arm of the industry-wide Pensions Equity Group. Endlessly curious, she believes that to address the structural shifts we all face requires creative thinking, and that success here lies in creating opportunities for new, and unexpected connections.
