Long lives, short changed
19 May, 2026
Around 15 million working-age people are not saving enough for retirement – yet the Second Pensions Commission's interim report suggests the policy response may arrive too late for the generation most at risk. Drawing on ILC's research on long lives and financial security, David Sinclair argues that a system built for shorter, more predictable working lives is failing self-employed people, carers and women disproportionately, and asks whether the UK has the courage to design a pensions settlement fit for the reality of long lives.
Today’s Pensions Commission interim report highlights that millions of us are heading towards later life without sufficient savings to maintain a decent standard of living.
People now approaching retirement, risk becoming one of the first generations in modern times to be worse off in retirement than those before them.
Women nearing retirement still hold substantially less private pension wealth than men. Among self-employed people, pension saving remains the exception rather than the norm. In too many households, saving adequately for later life has fallen away.
The first Pensions Commission, published over 20 years ago, transformed retirement saving through automatic enrolment. Millions more people now save into a workplace pension. The new State Pension strengthened the foundations of retirement income.
Pensioner poverty fell substantially between the late 1990s and early 2010s, driven by a combination of policy measures including Pension Credit, the Minimum Income Guarantee, and later the introduction of the new State Pension and the Triple Lock. Since then, pensioner poverty levels have broadly stabilised.
But the Commission’s interim report makes clear these reforms are no longer enough.
Defined benefit pensions have continued to decline. Voluntary saving has not filled the gap. Home ownership – once a key source of financial security in later life – is increasingly out of reach. At the same time, we are living longer, with widening inequalities in health and wealth as we age.
How much should we save?
The 8% automatic enrolment minimum was intended as a starting point. It has become the effective norm. Too many workers are saving at or near the minimum and assuming it will be sufficient.
At ILC, we have argued for auto-escalation – pension contributions rising gradually alongside wages – supported by a clear long-term trajectory for higher minimum saving rates.
Contribution rates are only part of the story. Investment returns and charges also matter. Over time, even modest differences in fees and returns can have a large impact on retirement outcomes. The Pension Schemes Bill provides an opportunity to strengthen governance and improve consolidation where schemes are inefficient or underperforming.
Who gets left behind?
Self-employed workers remain largely outside automatic enrolment. Many gig economy workers are not consistently captured by the system.
Carers – disproportionately women – continue to experience long-term financial penalties for unpaid care.
The UK has the second highest gender pensions gap in the OECD.
Too much pensions policy is still designed around an outdated model of working life: stable, full-time employment with predictable earnings.
Self-employed workers need pension saving mechanisms that work with irregular incomes.
And if we expect people to work longer, we must also confront inequalities in healthy life expectancy.
What happens when we retire?
Pension freedoms gave people greater control over how they access their savings. But greater freedom has also introduced new risks.
The Commission raises serious concerns about withdrawal rates and the risk of people running down their savings too quickly
Too many are making complex retirement income decisions without sufficient guidance or support, and without a clear sense of longevity risk. And while some may be drawing down too quickly – we know that others are underspending.
Managing a pension pot over a retirement that may last 25–30 years is inherently difficult. Most of us are not financial specialists.
The Commission is right to imply the need for stronger guardrails. A well-governed, low-cost default income pathway in retirement could be the norm for most savers, with active choice available where appropriate.
Alongside this, better decumulation products that build consumer confidence are long overdue.
Starting young
In One Hundred Not Out, ILC argued that Britain needs a new social contract for longevity.
That means helping younger people to save earlier. Supporting longer working lives in healthy and flexible ways. Recognising unpaid care. Protecting renters. And maintaining a State Pension that continues to prevent poverty in later life.
But why wait until 2027?
It is a pity we must wait until next year for the final report – and then several years more for implementation. For Generation X in particular, that delay may mean their retirement prospects do not improve in time to matter.
The UK needs a pensions system designed for the reality of long lives. We need to move quickly to deliver it.
David Sinclair
Chief Executive
David has worked in policy and research on ageing and demographic change for over 20 years. He is a recognised expert on longevity, with particular interests in older consumers, active ageing, financial services, adult vaccination and the role of technology in an ageing society.
He has deep knowledge of UK and global ageing issues, spanning health and care, pensions, housing, transport and consumption. David regularly presents internationally on longevity and demographic change and has published widely on topics including transport, technology, health and consumer markets.
David is an international advisor to the Sau Po Centre on Ageing at the University of Hong Kong and a member of the external advisory board for the University of Surrey Centre of Excellence on Ageing. He has worked with the pan-European AGE Platform for 15 years and is a former vice-chair of the government’s Consumer Expert Group for Digital Switchover.
Prior to joining the ILC, David was head of policy at Help the Aged, leading a team of policy advisers, and has held senior policy and public affairs roles across the voluntary sector.

